1895 – Horace Rawlins, Newport
1896 – James Foulis, Shinnecock Hills
1897 – Joe Lloyd, Chicago
1898 – Fred Herd, Myopia Hunt
1899 – Willie Smith, Baltimor
1900 – Harry Vardon, Chicago
1901 – Willie Anderson, Myopia Hunt
1902 – Laurence Auchterlonie, Garden City
1903 – Willie Anderson, Baltusrol
1904 – Willie Anderson, Glen View
1905 – Willie Anderson, Myopia Hunt
1906 – Alex Smith, Onwentsia
1907 – Alex Ross, Philadelphia Cricket
1908 – Fred McLeod, Myopia Hunt
1909 – George Sargent, Englewood
1910 – Alex Smith, Philadelphia Cricket
1911 – John J. McDermott, Chicago
1912 – John J. McDermott, Buffalo
1913 – Francis Ouimet (A), Brookline
1914 – Walter Hagen, Midlothian
1915 – Jerome D. Travers (A), Baltusrol
1916 – Charles Evans Jr. (A), Minikahda
1919 – Walter Hagen, Brae Burn
1920 – Edward Ray, Inverness
1921 – James M. Barnes, Columbia
1922 – Gene Sarazen, Skokie
1923 – Robert T. Jones Jr (A), Inwood
1924 – Cyril Walker, Oakland Hills
1925 – William Macfarlane, Worcester
1926 – Robert T. Jones Jr (A), Scioto
1927 – Tommy Armour, Oakmont
1928 – Johnny Farrell, Olympia Fields
1929 – Robert T. Jones Jr (A), Winged Foot